Melody is getting lots of love here in our ouse of girls!! One of her legs came off, but we did put it back on. . . she was bought used too, so perhaps it was not due to the manufacturer but previous owner that it happened. She arrived in impeccable condition though, so I know she was not roughed up at all, so I gave her 3 stars for durability. Our Melody doll we bought new is still intact w/out any injuries, so who knows. Just wanted to mention it though. Also, BOTH dolls had their necklaces that the doll wears break in seconds. . . they are so thin & it seems almost like they were dry rotted, if that is possible?!?! Anyway, lots of fun w/Melody =)!!